83 photos · MLS data verified October 9, 2026 · Updated every 15 min
$1,999,000
Active
2 Beds·2 Baths·1,193 sqft·5,227 sqft lot·Built 1953
420 Pilgrim Dr, Capitola, CA 95010
Listed 56 days ago · | MLS# ML82053104
$1,675/sqft
420 Pilgrim Dr is a single-level, 2-bedroom, 2-bath single family home in Capitola 95010 with 1,193 square feet of living space, built in 1953. It is listed at $1,999,000, or $1,675 per square foot. The three most recent 2-bedroom sales in 95010 closed between $550,000 and $3,000,000 ($524 to $1,828 per square foot).
Est. $12,717/moP&I $10,372 · Tax $2,082 · Insurance $262 · HOA $0Assumes 20% down ($399,800) at 6.75% · Contact Timothy for a lender referralAegis Luxury Real Estate is a licensed California real estate brokerage (DRE# 01328224) and is not a mortgage lender, mortgage broker, or loan originator. The figures shown are estimates for general reference only and do not constitute a loan offer, pre-approval, pre-qualification, or commitment to lend. Estimates use a property tax rate of 1.25% of home price annually. Actual rates, payments, taxes, and insurance vary by lender and borrower qualifications. Contact Timothy for a referral to one of our preferred lending partners.
Single Family Price Position in Capitola
$1.2M$2.4M
38Active in Capitola
17Active Single Family Homes
5.4 moInventory
Why This Home Stands Out
🏠
Single Level, 2 Bed / 2 Bath, 1,193 sqft
Everything on one floor. Built in 1953, attached 2-car garage.
Best fit forActive BuyersCapitola SearchersMove-Up / Move-In
About 420 Pilgrim Dr
Just reduced 201,000! Such a quiet neighborhood of beautiful homes yet just a short walk to Capitola village, Gayles Bakery and of course the beach. This mid century home on a quiet street has just had an extensive upgrade of both home and landscape with beautiful pavers, a natural gas firepit to gather around in the evenings, artificial turf, new fencing, landscape lighting, irrigation and so much more. The home features a new smooth stucco exterior, refinished white oak floors, all new Milgard windows, interior doors, interior and exterior paint, new stainless appliances, recessed lighting, nest thermostat, ring doorbell, security cameras and new electrical panels . Indoor laundry room. Much of the original 1950's charm has been retained in the kitchen and bathrooms. A two car garage and plenty of driveway parking is a rare bonus in Capitola. Inside laundry room. Enticing areas in both the front and back yards for relaxing and entertaining. Private backyard with no rear neighbors. Mature producing avocado, orange and lime trees. A location like this doesn't come along every day, just above the activity in the village, yet such a quiet street. Five minute walk to the Esplanade and beach!
MLS ID #ML82053104, Jeffrey Badzik. Listing provided by BRG Realty · MLSListings Inc.
Interested in 420 Pilgrim Dr?
Get a personalized analysis with comp data, offer strategy, and neighborhood context.
Property Details for 420 Pilgrim Dr
Overview
- Property Type
- Single Family Residence
- Year Built
- 1953
- Stories
- 1
- Bedrooms
- 2
- Bathrooms
- 2 Full
- Living Area
- 1,193 sqft
- Lot Size
- 5,227 sqft (0.12 acres)
- Price/sqft
- $1,675
- Status
- Active
Interior
- Kitchen
- Dining area
- Fireplace
- Gas burning
- Heating
- Central forced air, gas
- Cooling
- Ceiling fan
- Flooring
- Wood
- Family Room
- None
Exterior and Parking
- Garage
- Attached, 2 spaces
- Roof
- Shingle
- Foundation
- Concrete perimeter
- Zoning
- R-1
Community and HOA
- Utilities
- Natural gas available, Public, Water public
- County
- Santa Cruz
- City
- Capitola
Schools
- School District
- Soquel Union Elementary
- Capitola Schools
- View Capitola schools
Listing
- MLS Number
- ML82053104
- Listed
- August 14, 2026
- Days on Market
- 56
- Listing Agent
- Jeffrey Badzik
- Listing Brokerage
- BRG Realty
- Data Verified
- October 9, 2026
Source: MLSListings Inc. School attendance boundaries are set by the district and can change; verify directly with the district.
Free from Aegis · Updated for October 2026
Three Capitola Reports the Listing Does Not Give You
📄Capitola Market ReportFree 9-page PDF with bedroom breakdowns, comp data and pricing trends, updated monthly.Email Me the Report →📋Capitola Buyer BriefA personalized brief with comp data, offer strategy and neighborhood context.Email Me the Report →🎯Capitola Offer StrategyComp analysis and bid recommendations before you write an offer on this home.Email Me the Report →
Location
420 Pilgrim Dr, Capitola, CA 95010 · Santa Cruz County
Market Context
Price Positioning
🏠 Inventory: 11 2-bedroom homes and 17 single family homes currently active in Capitola.
Source: MLSListings Inc. Timothy Alston, Broker, DRE# 01328224.
Want to know what this home will actually sell for? Get a data-backed offer range based on recent comparable sales.
Get My Offer Range →Frequently Asked Questions
Listed at $1,999,000 ($1,675/sqft). The three most recent 2-bedroom sales in 95010 closed at $524 to $1,828 per sqft.
Listed August 14, 2026. That is 56 days on market as of October 9, 2026.
Est. $12,717/mo with 20% down ($399,800) at 6.75%. That is principal and interest $10,372, property tax $2,082 and insurance $262. The assumptions and lender disclosure are with the payment estimate at the top of this page.
There are 38 active listings in Capitola: 11 are 2-bedroom and 17 are single family homes.
The three most recent 2-bedroom sales in Capitola 95010 closed at $550,000, $575,000 and $3,000,000, or $524 to $1,828 per sqft.
Yes. As of October 9, 2026, 420 Pilgrim Dr is an active listing at $1,999,000. It is a 2-bedroom, 2-bath single family home.
See This Home · Scheduling Is Free
Timothy Alston
Broker · DRE# 01328224 · Over 23 Years Experience
Tour 420 Pilgrim Dr
Request a private showing and Timothy will confirm the time with you.
or call (408) 207-4593 nowBy proceeding, you consent to be contacted by Aegis Luxury Real Estate at the number and email provided. Privacy Policy
Not ready to tour yet?
🎯 Get the Offer Strategy report →Free Capitola Reports
October 2026. Built on the same live MLS data Timothy uses with clients.
Market ReportEmail it to me →Buyer BriefEmail it to me →Offer StrategyEmail it to me →
For Homeowners
Get My Home's Value
What would your Capitola home sell for today?
Capitola homes sold at N/A% of list price in a median of N/A days in the latest closed month.
N/A%Sale-to-List, recent
N/AMedian Days, recent
Free. No obligation. Takes 30 seconds.
More in Capitola
View All Listings →Explore Capitola real estate
Recently Sold in Capitola
Closed within 6 months · 2 bed / similar sqft · Capitola 95010
1139 Callas Ln 4
Sold $575,000
2 bd · 1 ba · 960 sqft
$598/sqft
$598/sqft
Closed Sep 28, 2026 · 55 days on market
MLS ID #ML82052609, Amy Jeske. Listing provided by Coldwell Banker Realty · MLSListings Inc.4160 Jade St 13
Sold $550,000
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,050 sqft
$523/sqft
$523/sqft
Closed Sep 14, 2026 · 17 days on market
MLS ID #ML82047067, Teresa Marlow. Listing provided by Compass · MLSListings Inc.4840 Cliff Dr
Sold $3,000,000
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,641 sqft
$1,828/sqft
$1,828/sqft
Closed Sep 02, 2026
MLS ID #ML82063865, Strock Team. Listing provided by eXp Realty of California Inc · MLSListings Inc.Source: MLSListings Inc. Closed sales data.
For Homeowners
Your neighbors are selling. Should you?
What happens when the right home lists and nobody knows you are looking for it?
In Capitola, 1 new listings hit the MLS this week. By the time most search sites update, the window has already narrowed.
Nearby Homes
View All 29 →
New
$1,077,000
300 Plum St 77, Capitola
3 bed2 bath1,623 sqft
MLS ID #ML82056236, John Guernsey. Listing provided by eXp Realty of California Inc · MLSListings Inc.
New
$925,000
825 Balboa Ave 205, Capitola
2 bed1.5 bath922 sqft
MLS ID #ML82052831, Erica Pittman. Listing provided by Coastal Dream Realty · MLSListings Inc.
New
$729,950
815 Balboa Ave 310, Capitola
2 bed1 bath704 sqft
MLS ID #ML82054613, Christy Whiting Wohlert. Listing provided by David Lyng Real Estate · MLSListings Inc.
Similar Homes
View All 11 →2 bed · $1.5M-$2.5M · Active in Capitola
New This Week
$2,399,000
529 Capitola Ave, Capitola
2 bed1.5 bath1,426 sqft
MLS ID #ML82056643, Diana Mercer. Listing provided by Compass · MLSListings Inc.
New This Week
$2,199,000
539 Riverview Dr, Capitola
2 bed2 bath1,024 sqft
MLS ID #ML82059801, Lila Veik. Listing provided by eXp Realty of California Inc · MLSListings Inc.
Nearby Open Houses
See All →OPEN SAT, 12PM TO 3PM$1,077,000
300 Plum St 77, Capitola
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,623 sqft
MLS ID #ML82056236, John Guernsey. Listing provided by eXp Realty of California Inc · MLSListings Inc.
OPEN SAT, 12PM TO 3PM$925,000
825 Balboa Ave 205, Capitola
2 bd · 1.5 ba · 922 sqft
MLS ID #ML82052831, Erica Pittman. Listing provided by Coastal Dream Realty · MLSListings Inc.
OPEN SUN, 12PM TO 3PM$869,000
431 Capitola Ave, Capitola
3 bd · 2 ba · 880 sqft
MLS ID #ML82062991, Tyanne Scaletti. Listing provided by Bailey Properties · MLSListings Inc.
OPEN FRI, 1PM TO 4PM$3,995,000
1500 Wharf Rd 22, Capitola
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,850 sqft
MLS ID #ML82041044, Paul Bailey. Listing provided by Bailey Properties · MLSListings Inc.
OPEN SAT, 1PM TO 3PM$848,000
815 Balboa Ave 106, Capitola
2 bd · 1.5 ba · 774 sqft
MLS ID #ML82059372, Aaron Derbacher. Listing provided by KW Bay Area Estates · MLSListings Inc.
Buyers
See 420 Pilgrim Dr before the weekend
Listed 56 days ago.
Questions
Talk to Timothy directly
Timothy Alston, Broker, DRE# 01328224. Over 23 years in Silicon Valley real estate.
Explore Capitola Homes
Capitola by Listing Status
Explore Nearby Santa Cruz County Cities
Santa Cruz County Market Brief
- Weekly market data
- New listing alerts
- Price trend analysis
- Unsubscribe anytime
You'll receive a confirmation email. No spam. One-click unsubscribe.
